Who are the Top Football Players from New York City?



People from New York are renowned for their tenacity and capacity for survival. As a result, it is considered that New York’s football players are among the toughest around. This list is not only for those who racked up the most absurd stats and sold the most tickets. These players handled the physical rigors of the game, whether it was giving it out or taking hits and coming back for more. Learn more about the Sports scene in NYC. Visit New York City – A Playground for Champions and Epic Sporting Showdowns

Greatest Football Players from New York

Rob Gronkowski

Rob Gronkowski, three-time Super Bowl champion

Rob Gronkowski is widely recognized as the greatest tight end of all time and one of the finest American football players of his age. Rob Gronkowski is not only one of the most well-liked athletes but also a tight end who holds several National Football League (NFL) records.

Frank Reich 

Frank Reich behind enemy lines

Former American football player Frank Reich spent 14 seasons as a quarterback in the National Football League (NFL). He is presently the head coach of the well-liked Indianapolis Colts of the NFL. He has also served as a member of the coaching staffs for the Philadelphia Eagles, San Diego Chargers, and Arizona Cardinals over the years.

Roosevelt Brown

Brown, who was ranked 57th among all-time best players by Sporting News, was a master pass-blocker. Being a monster in the run game with his fast feet, he was one of the first offensive lineman to concentrate in pass protection. Roosevelt’s accomplishment altered offensive linemen scouting practices because of how highly now value linemen with fast feet. One of the finest offensive linemen in Giants history, Brown has been named to the All-NFL team eight times.

Wayne Chrebet

You would have a hard time finding a harder and more courageous receiver than veteran Jet Wayne Chrebet, even if he may not quite fall under the “biggest” category. The 11-year NFL career of the Hofstra graduate was made possible by his tenacity and resilience. Chrebet was never the most physically powerful receiver on the field, but on any given Sunday, the man would give up his body to make plays when they were required.

Because of the incredible amount of grit and tenacity he shown, Chrebet’s jersey is a must-have for Jets fans to acquire in their vintage collection. Chrebet was consistently a bright spot and a fan favorite in years for New York that were otherwise relatively thin in terms of victories.

Wesley Walker

Walker was unique because he managed to play at such a high level for so long while only being able to see with one good eye. Walker was able to average an astounding 19 yards per reception over the course of 13 seasons.

The fact that Walker was able to play at such a high level makes it even more astounding that he was able to overcome a condition that would have ended the careers of most players. Walker’s severe loss of peripheral vision made it more difficult for him to see other defenders, which increased his chance of injury every time he ran a route. Just think about how challenging it would be for him.

Justin Tuck

Justin Tuck at NY Knicks vs Miami Heat Game

Tuck is a great player when he’s healthy, and his greatest years are still ahead of him. But, to be really honest, his fiercest helmet ever manufactured is the main reason he made this historical list. Although it must have been in Tuck’s back of mind, he supposedly received a new helmet because opponents were jabbing at his facemask to worsen his neck ailment. Tuck is on his way to become one of the finest defenders in Giants history, helmet and all.

Mark Gastineau

Gastineau was a crucial component of the renowned “New York Sack Exchange” and the defensive lineman equivalent of Joe Namath. When Gastineau set a new record by recording 22 sacks in a single season in 1983, he was named defensive player of the year. Michael Strahan eventually shattered his record for the most sacks in a single season in 2001, after holding the mark for 17 years (although there was some debate over the validity of his 22.5 sacks).

Regularly sacking the opposition quarterback wasn’t enough for Gastineau, so he went above and above with his sack dance to put opponents on notice. This started a pattern of post-sack celebrations that continues to this day.

Harry Carson

The great Giants defense that won a championship in 1986 had Carson as its captain, but he wasn’t exactly the result of being surrounded by exceptional talent. The greatest inside linebacker in game history was considered to be Carson. The seven-time All-Pro and future Hall of Famer was a pillar of the Giants’ defense for 13 seasons. Because he played next to Lawrence Taylor, Carson is occasionally overlooked, yet he is still among the finest linebackers in the history of the sport.

Mark Bavaro

In his six seasons with the Giants, Bavaro—the lone tight end on our list—became a fan favorite. Bavaro was a first-team All-Pro in 1986 and 1987. In his six years in New York, he caught 28 touchdown passes, but it was a single play on a Monday night against the 49ers that cemented his reputation as one of the game’s hardest players.

After receiving a pass from Phil Simms, Bavaro simply refused to fall, dragging opponents for roughly twenty yards behind him. Since that time, Bavaro has solidified his reputation as one of the gritty, roughest tight ends to ever don a Giants uniform.

Rosey Grier

Grier is more recognized for his participation in the Los Angeles Rams’ Fearsome Foursome, possibly the strongest defensive line in NFL history. Nevertheless, Grier has played a significant role in the Giants’ defense ever since they selected him in the 1955 selection. After his playing days, Grier sought an acting career, which could have concealed the vicious defensive lineman he was for the 11 years he spent in the NFL. Grier was one of the finest defensive tackles to ever play the game, despite his affable on-air demeanor.

Mo Lewis

Lewis was a relentless force in the heart of the Jets’ defense, even though the fact that he took Drew Bledsoe out of the game that gave Tom Brady his professional start did not help the Jets. Lewis, a three-time Pro Bowler and two-time All-Pro, led the Jets’ defense for seven years in a row. Lewis was one of the best Jets of his day, even though Jets fans wish he hadn’t been so harsh on Drew Bledsoe in the hit that would plague the team for the following ten years.

George Martin

Not just his career total of 96 sacks with the Giants, but also the fact that he was able to secure every single one of them while playing as a 3-4 defensive end, made players like Martin stand out.

Martin was able to get to the passer going through double teams as easily as a “regular” 4-3 defensive end could against single blocks, despite the fact that most 3-4 ends are geared to manage gaps and contain runs. Martin was a continuous threat to produce a game-changing play, regardless of position, on the field, and he also added seven defensive touchdowns.

John Riggins

Riggins was a tremendous player for the Jets prior to signing with Washington as a free agency following the 1975 season, even though he is more remembered for being a Redskin than a Jet (and the Jets are still mad with themselves for not retaining him in New York).

Riggins has the statistics and awards to support his notoriety, but he is better recognized for his muscular running technique and skill on the goal line. No linebacker wanted to face him because he was the kind of back, they dreaded playing. Although he undoubtedly gained the most of his notoriety and wealth as a Redskin, he was also a fantastic player with the Jets for a number of years.

Jim Burt

Burt’s tenacity and perseverance allowed him to overcome being an undrafted free agent and earn a spot in the Pro Bowl. The 1986 NFC Championship game was where Burt best demonstrated his reputation as a strong, tireless worker as he knocked out Joe Montana on an intercepted ball that led to a touchdown for the Giants. On their road to the Super Bowl, the Giants were able to thrash the 49ers 49-3. Explore more of NYC’s Best Teams. Visit What Makes the U.S. Open in Flushing Meadows a Must-Watch Tennis Event?

Darrelle Revis

Darrelle Revis

Since 2009, Revis has been playing at a level that no cornerback in NFL history has ever achieved. Whether it’s Terrell Owens, Larry Fitzgerald, Calvin Johnson, or Andre Johnson, Revis just shuts down the best receivers with remarkable regularity. When Revis blows a catch, it really generates news coverage.

Additionally, Revis is a great tackler who is not hesitant to lay the wood. He even has his own island, which automatically places him among the deadliest characters in New York. In addition to being the greatest Jet in history, Darrelle will be remembered as the greatest cornerback to ever play the position when he hangs up his cleats.

Matt Snell

Snell actually played for both the Jets and the Giants, but the championship game in which the Jets shocked the heavily-favored Colts to start the AFL and NFL merger marked his career. By repeatedly giving the ball to Snell, the Jets were able to defeat the Colts 16-7 in a ball-control, possession game. He amassed 121 yards on 30 attempts for the Jets’ lone Super Bowl score. While Namath receives all of the credit for delivering on his promise, Snell played an equally, if not even greater, role in the Jets’ lone championship victory.

Mel Hein

Hein had a particular reputation for being tough and was possibly the greatest offensive tackle to play for the Giants. Hein was an outstanding linebacker in addition to being a road-grader in the run game and a brick wall in pass protection. Except for the one occasion he injured his nose, which he quickly healed before returning to the game, he never took breaks from playing.

Curtis Martin

Even though Curtis Martin wasn’t the most physically gifted running back, it would be hard to find a player who was as tough, astute, or as full of character as Martin. Martin quietly climbed to the fourth place on the list of all-time rushers because to his toughness and dependability.

Martin, though, was more than simply a back. He freely stated that he did not really enjoy football; rather, he utilized it as a means of helping people and transforming what had previously been a life of violence into a life of influence. Martin is among the worst players ever to play the game only based on his attitude and leadership. In addition to learning about Top Football Players in NYC, discover the most iconic moments in NYC Sports scene. Visit What Are the Most Iconic Sports Moments and Achievements in New York City History?

Michael Strahan

Michael Strahan

When he appears on pregame shows and television advertisements, Strahan may come out as a lovely man, but on the field, he was a different type of person. Strahan, who currently holds the record for most sacks in a season (22.5), played defensive end for 15 years while maintaining an incredibly high degree of consistency.

Strahan was the face of the Giants defense for more than a decade thanks to his performance as well as the mindset he brought to the field until he retired in 2007 after winning a Super Bowl. Strahan will be remembered as one of the Giants team’s most recognizable faces because he was a fantastic player and person.

Joe Klecko

The legendary Jets defensive line, known as the “New York Sack Exchange,” had a ton of skill, but Joe Klecko stood out as the greatest player in the unit. When the Jets switched to a 3-4 defense in 1985, Klecko played defensive tackle, defensive end, and even some nose tackle. Klecko got an incredible 7.5 sacks while playing nose tackle, where fighting double teams is common.

One of the few bright lights in the years following Namath’s retirement was the NYSE, and Klecko was largely responsible for their success. The Gatorade bath, which is now a standard celebration in many sports, was also created by Klecko. He was still a fan favorite in New York thanks to his reputation as a physically demanding, hard-working player.

Sam Huff

Sam Huff in 2022

Huff came dangerously close to giving up on football at one time because he couldn’t find a spot on the defense. That is, until Vince Lombardi, an assistant coach, persuaded him to come back to camp and join Tom Landry’s ground-breaking 4-3 defense.

Huff has since modernized the 4-3 linebacker position. He was selected for the All-Pro team six times and appeared in five Pro Bowls. Huff was renowned for taking on the top backs in the game head-to-head and knocking them out with crushing hits.

Lawrence Taylor

Lawrence Taylor signing autographs

Taylor undoubtedly dominated games as a pass-rushing linebacker, but sadly his legal troubles are now garnering more attention than his Hall of Fame career. Taylor recorded 132.5 sacks over the course of his 13-year career, including 20.5 in 1986. However, Taylor’s impact went beyond his sack totals. This was the person who, after fracturing Joe Theismann’s leg, put an end to his career.

Ron Jaworski, the quarterback for the Eagles at the time, was known for approaching the line and pleading with his offensive linemen to ensure that Taylor was blocked (which, more often than not, was a last resort in itself). Taylor, one of the best players in Giants history, not only changed the way linebackers were played, but also earned a reputation as one of the league’s baddest ballers.


In a nutshell New York has given rise to a sizable number of gifted football players who have made a big impact on the game. These athletes have achieved success both in the college and professional ranks, demonstrating their abilities and winning praise. Famous athletes like Joe Montana, Jim Brown, and Franco Harris have cemented their spots as some of football’s all-time greats. Additionally, New York continues to develop outstanding football talent with the rise of contemporary players like Odell Beckham Jr. and Aaron Donald. The state’s football heritage is unquestionably great overall and it keeps getting better with each new generation of players.

Share this

Recent articles

More like this